This is a story about my witnessing first-hand the demise of respect for the public space commons in one university library, over a period of approximately five years between 1999 and 2004.
Here I will NOT name names, either personal or institutional. The greater aim is to illustrate the gravity of a problem and the overt denial of this problem that still exists today.
Temple Of Self Knowledge
For many years, I found great intellectual enrichment in libraries of various universities that I attended, both as an enrolled student and as an independent learner. One university in particular became my greatest resource, because I came to live in the neighborhood where this university was located.
Part of my daily routine was walking to the library of this university for reasons of doing independent research on various subjects of great interest to me. At the time under consideration here, I was not an enrolled student. Instead, I took advantage of the university’s “Friends Of The Library” membership plan that allowed any citizen to buy a library card and to use the materials there. I also took advantage of the university’s offering of public access computers, where any citizen could log into databases or log onto the internet.
The university’s public access computers were in an area of low ambient light, accented with track lights, sitting on high tables, where bar stools enabled users either to stand or to sit in unconstrained postures on the high stools. Since I was a fitness instructor at the time, I appreciated both the stand-up option and the cave-like light partitioning amid the pleasing openness of the hallway commons.
Insidious Noise Invasion
This temple of knowledge, however, slowly became incapable of supporting serious study. The reasons included:
excessive, unchecked cell phone use,
loud (sometimes obscene) conversations,
noisy library orientations trampling through the area, led by a library staff teacher who seemed to love the sound of his own voice as much as his dedication to the library profession.
Here in this same area of the library, I had grown accustomed to a level of contemplative quiet that had not changed in over a decade. I had arrived at some of my greatest insights in this quiet. Now I felt assaulted in a space that supposedly enabled public access to information, unable to assimilate the information that I had accessed because of all the invasive noise.
The public access provision of the university library, thus, became a superficial appearance with little true utility. Perhaps this superficial appearance served to strengthen the library’s mission statement or funding eligibility, but it no longer did so truthfully, in the manner that I had grown to expect of a UNIVERSITY LIBRARY.
Making Noise About Noise
Consequently, I began to do what is difficult for people, quiet by nature, to do – make noise, or complain, about the noise. I made daily approaches to library staff, asking them to control the invasive noises. I had to walk away from my computer station, risking loss of my station to someone else, or risking disappearance of the noise disturbance in that exact moment when it occurred, only to have a library staff person arrive where now the disturbance no longer existed. In the time it took me to walk away to complain, the noise could go away, yet an instant later, a different disturbance could replace it, motivating me to walk away again, only to return to another disappeared disturbance.
I made numerous such approaches to library staff, becoming very frustrated by the deterioration of my once quiet independent study area. Because these approaches did little good, I began emailing the Dean of the library, expressing my amazement at how the commons atmosphere had deteriorated into a noisy circus. This Dean responded in a predictably diplomatic tone, but a tone that was lighthearted and dismissive. His tone was one of utter acceptance of the noise. My tone was one of utter rejection of the noise, utter insult, and utter disbelief of the Dean’s attitude.
Challenging The Noise Paradigm
I, thus, verbally challenged the Dean’s email responses with biting criticisms. I never cursed him. I never used words to attack his person. I never threatened his person in any way. I questioned the ethics that supported his attitude. I questioned the morals. I questioned his duty, his responsibility, and his very position as Dean of a UNIVERSITY LIBRARY.
In my emails, I described in vivid detail the sorts of behavior that I witnessed daily as a person on the front lines of his operation. I quoted the cursing I heard over cell phones. I reported loud partying crowds getting off elevators nearby. Again, the Dean’s tone was compliant and dismissive, as if this sort of behavior were the norm in his UNIVERSITY LIBRARY. Again, I challenged his tone, his words, his definitions, and his whole demeanor towards this situation.
Paradigm Police
One day I was startled by a loud knock on my private apartment door, accompanied by a loud voice announcing, “Police department!” The Dean’s response, thus, was to dispatch campus police to where I lived.
I opened my apartment door, and confirmed with the police Captain that he did, in fact, hold copies of emails that I had written – no cursing, no threats, no personal attacking, remember, just pointed philosophical challenges to the paradigm that the library Dean seemed to endorse. As I looked down stairs leading up to my door, I saw the police Captain’s Lieutenant crouched in readiness at the base of those stairs. Was there a S.W.A.T. team outside too, I wondered.
The police Captain’s explanation was that he was there, “to assess me as a potential threat to the university.” I invited him in. I assured him that I had no stash of weapons in my closet. He advised me, “You need to watch what you say.” I responded, “This is a free country”, with some further defense that philosophical criticism was not a crime. He did not like this, but he left with full assurance that I was NOT a criminal threat to the university that the library Dean had led him to consider.
College Education?
I got some good education that day, on the subject of challenging a paradigm that has solidified through funding, through salaried positions, through self-concepts, and through prized reputations within a given profession. I learned that university librarians could foster questionable standards to please tuition-paying students, even if such standards conflicted with what most people considered (and still consider) a very important attribute of libraries.
Little did I realize that a new library paradigm favoring group chatter had insidiously usurped a traditional library standard favoring individual study. The quiet commons had become the noisy commons. The fear of silence in Western cultures had reached new heights. The library profession now endorsed this paradigm of noise over silence. THIS is what I was threatening. THIS appeared to be why a university library Dean really summoned police to my private living quarters – I did NOT threaten the man or the university, but I threatened a new paradigm.
The library Dean easily subsumed my paradigmatic threat into a criminal threat to his university, during a time when college campuses nationwide were paranoid about terrorism, mass shootings, and other crimes. The Dean, thus, misrepresented my threat, possibly innocently as a precaution, which would have been forgivable, or intentionally as a power play, which would have been an abuse of his position.
Either way, the Dean’s actions illustrate how a new noise paradigm has gained a powerful grip on people who are in charge of operating libraries today.
Bassackwards
Librarians today simply have become blind to noise. Librarians have become noise-accepting addicts, engulfed so deeply in a problem that they are parts of the problem, like drug addicts who are too far inside their own bad habits to realize them.
Modern librarians have become defiant children wanting to break the barrier of quiet, in order to escape feared stereotypes resulting from misperceptions of quiet and fears of silence.
Modern librarians want to condemn quiet people to tomblike containers, walled off from beautiful, open, well-lit public-space commons. This is backwards. The noisemakers are the ones who should be behind walls, leaving an open commons in the most ground-level state of respectful quiet, like the cosmic zero-point energy field that is the deceptively calm, yet infinitely rich ground of all creation.
, Library Noise Horror Story – When Noble Intentions Go Terribly Wrong www.ozeldersin.com bitirme tezi,ödev,proje dönem ödevi bitirme tezi örnekleri,tez hazırlama kuralları,tez merkezi, ,,bitirme tezi örnekleri ,bitirme tezi örneği ,bitirme tezi konuları ,örnek bitirme tezi ,lisans bitirme tezi ,lisans bitirme tezi örnekleri ,bitirme tezi indir ,bitirme tezi yazım kuralları ,endüstri mühendisliği bitirme tezi konuları ,bitirme tezi nedir ,bitirme tezi sunumu ,bitirme tezi ingilizce ,üniversite bitirme tezi ,bitirme tezi kapağı ,ktü bitirme tezi ,bitirme tezi önsöz ,tanrının bitirme tezi ,bitirme tezi pdf ,bitirme tezi örnek ,bitirme tezi kuralları ,bitirme tezi taslağı ,bitirme tezi pornosu , ,tez hazirlama ,tez hazırlama merkezleri ,tez hazırlama fiyatları ,tez hazırlama teknikleri ,tez hazırlama programı ,tez hazırlama yönergesi ,tez kapağı hazırlama ,tez içindekiler hazırlama , ,bitirme tezi nasıl hazırlanır ,bitirme tezi nasıl yazılır ,yüksek lisans tezi nasıl yazılır ,yüksek lisans tezi nasıl hazırlanır ,doktora tezi nasıl yazılır ,lisans tezi nasıl yazılır , ,tez merkezi ,tez hazırlama merkezi ,ödev tez merkezi ,türkiye tez merkezi ,tez yazim merkezi ,tez tarama merkezi ,tez araştırma merkezi ,osym tez merkezi ,tez arama merkezi ,akademi tez merkezi ,istanbul tez merkezi ,tez proje yazım merkezi ,yüksek öğretim tez merkezi , ,tez yazma ,tez yazma fiyatları ,tez yazma teknikleri ,tez yazma programı ,tez yazma kurallari , ,odev ,ödev kapağı hazırlama ,odev kapaklari ,ödev yapma siteleri ,ödev hazırlama ,tez ödev ,ödev yapılır ,ödev yapan siteler ,ödev kapakları hazırla ,odev sitesi ,ödev bul ,ödev hazırlama siteleri ,ödev bulma siteleri ,odev tez ,ödev yaptırmak istiyorum ,odev siteleri , ,yüksek lisans proje örnekleri ,yüksek lisans proje konuları ,tezsiz yüksek lisans proje örnekleri ,yüksek lisans tez ,lisans tez , ,bitirme projesi ,bitirme projesi örnekleri ,bitirme projesi örneği ,bitirme projesi konuları ,lisans bitirme projesi ,bilgisayar mühendisliği bitirme projesi örnekleri , ,tez konulari ,yüksek lisans tez konuları ,muhasebe tez konuları ,kamu yönetimi tez konuları ,psikoloji tez konuları ,ekonomi tez konuları ,halkla ilişkiler tez konuları ,maliye tez konuları ,insan kaynakları tez konuları ,bankacılık tez konuları ,dış ticaret tez konuları ,hazır tez konuları ,finans tez konuları ,endüstri mühendisliği tez konuları ,maliye bölümü tez konuları ,turizm tez konuları ,lisans tez konuları ,besyo tez konuları ,yönetim ve organizasyon tez konuları ,lojistik tez konuları ,muhasebe ile ilgili tez konuları ,istatistik tez konuları ,kimya tez konuları ,iktisat tez konulari ,doktora tez konuları ,bankacılıkla ilgili tez konuları ,biyokimya tez konuları ,ekonometri tez konuları ,bilgisayar tez konuları ,gazetecilik tez konuları ,hukuk tez konuları ,finansla ilgili tez konuları ,sosyoloji tez konulari , ,tez konusu belirleme ,tez konusu bulma ,tez konusu ,tez konusu bul ,tez konusu bulmak ,iktisat tez konusu ,tez konusu seçme ,doktora tez konusu ,tez konusu arama , ,lisans bitirme tezleri ,doktora tezleri ,lisans tezleri ,üniversite tezleri ,üniversite bitirme tezleri ,iktisat tezleri ,yuksek lisans tezleri ,pazarlama tezleri ,bitirme tezleri örnekleri ,turizm tezleri ,bankacılık tezleri ,uluslararası ilişkiler tezleri ,işletme tezleri ,araştırma tezleri ,eğitim tezleri , ,tezler ,örnek tezler ,pazarlama ile ilgili tezler ,hazir tezler ,yapılmış tezler ,bankacılıkla ilgili tezler ,ödev ve tezler ,uluslararası tezler , ,bitirme ödevi ,bitirme ödevi örnekleri ,bitirme ödevi örneği ,bitirme ödevi nasıl hazırlanır ,bitirme ödevi konuları , ,yüksek lisans tez örnekleri ,tez ornekleri ,lisans tez örnekleri ,bitirme tez örnekleri ,tez örnekleri indir ,tez anket örnekleri ,besyo tez örnekleri ,muhasebe tez örnekleri ,üniversite tez örnekleri ,sakarya üniversitesi tez örnekleri , ,tez yazim kurallari ,tez yazım kılavuzu ,tez yazım formatı ,tez yazım ,lisans tez yazım kuralları ,tez yazım programı ,ege üniversitesi tez yazım kılavuzu ,tez yazım teknikleri ,tez yazim klavuzu ,ankara tez yazım merkezleri ,yıldız teknik üniversitesi tez yazım kılavuzu ,ytü lisans tez yazım kılavuzu , ,tez nasil yazilir ,tez ödevi nasıl hazırlanır ,tez nasıl yapılır ,tez nasil hazirlanir ,tez konusu nasıl bulunur ,lisans tez nasıl hazırlanır , ,tez siteleri ,tez arama siteleri ,tez araştırma siteleri ,tez indirme siteleri ,tez bulma siteleri ,ödev tez siteleri , ,işletme tez konuları ,işletme bölümü tez konuları ,tez konuları işletme ,işletme tez konusu ,işletme yönetimi tez konuları ,işletme tez , ,doktora tezi ,lisans tezi ,lisans tezi örneği ,yuksek lisans tezi ,yüksek lisans tezi örneği ,pazarlama tezi , ,pazarlama tez konuları ,pazarlama tez konusu ,pazarlama ile ilgili tez konuları ,pazarlama tez ,pazarlama tez örnekleri , ,uluslararası ilişkiler tez konuları ,uluslararası ilişkiler bölümü tez konuları ,uluslararası tez arama ,siyaset bilimi ve uluslararası ilişkiler tez konuları ,uluslararası ilişkiler bitirme tez konuları , ,tez ,tez arama ,tez tarama ,tez indir ,tez yazan yerler ,tez yazmak ,tez nedir ,tez önerisi örneği ,tez bul ,tez ödevleri ,tez formatı ,tez yazimi ,tez sitesi ,tez arama motoru ,tez yazdırmak istiyorum ,örnek tez önerileri ,tez araştırma ,tez yazilir ,tez çalışmaları ,yok tez arama ,tez ödevi ,tez danışmanlığı ,osym tez ,tez danışmanlık ,tez ara ,tez hazırlamak ,tez bulma ,tez merkezleri ,ücretli tez yazımı ,tez proje ,örnek tez yazımı ,tez danışmanı ,tez yazdirma ,tez ornegi ,tez destek ,tez yardım ,san tez projeleri ,tez yazdırmak isteyenler ,tez başlıkları ,ornek tez ,hazır tez indir ,istanbul tez ,tez projesi ,tez bankasi ,tez yaptırma ,tez yazanlar ,tez yazdırmak ,akademik tez ,tez kapaklari ,tez hazırlanır ,üniversite tez ,hazir tez ,tez düzenleme ,proje tez ,tez önerileri ,tez analizi ,tez yapan yerler ,tez araştır ,örnek tez çalışması ,tez düzeltme ,tez ler ,bilimsel tez ,tez araştırması ,tez yazılır ankara ,ankarada tez yazan yerler ,tez yazılır istanbul ,sakarya üniversitesi tez ,tez yazımı ankara ,tez arsivi ,tez yapılır ,tez istanbul ,tez çevirisi ,tez başlığı , ,bitirme projeleri ,uluslararası ilişkiler bölümü ,lisansüstü eğitim ,iktisadi ve idari bilimler ,mezuniyet projesi ,üniversite bitirme projeleri ,yıldız teknık unıversıtesı ,elektronik bitirme projeleri ,idari bilimler fakültesi ,yıldız teknik ü ,uluslararası ilişkiler fakültesi ,yazim kilavuzuzu ,iktisadi ve idari bilimler fakultesi ,üniversite kılavuzları ,uluslararası ılıskıler derslerı , , , ,